69° Galesburg
Student Read, Student Written, Student Led Since 1878

The Knox Student

Student Read, Student Written, Student Led Since 1878

The Knox Student

Student Read, Student Written, Student Led Since 1878

The Knox Student


This poll has ended.

Student Senate recently passed a bylaw requiring a club representative at senate meetings. They have since paused the bylaw. Are you in favor of it?


Sorry, there was an error loading this poll.

Editors Roundtable: Student Senate Bylaw

The new student senate bylaw – which has been paused – would’ve required club representatives to attend senate meetings, and it came from a good place. Student Senate wants to improve communication with clubs, I also want improved communication between student orgs and clubs.

But the roll out, and then roll back in, of the bylaw was not communicated well. Senate discussed and passed the bylaw without mentioning it to the campus community. Many people learned about it from a TKS article, and then protested. So, senate rolled back the bylaw. I appreciate that they listened, and are taking steps to work with the community. But again, they didn’t announce the roll back to the campus community either.

Senate says they want to meet with student organization leaders to talk about the bylaw before un-pausing it. But as a student org leader, I haven’t heard anything from them about this.

I also want better communication between orgs and senate. I’m not opposed to the bylaw, though I do think it has some flaws. But if the goal is better communication, then senate should practice communicating their proposed solutions.

Eleanor Lindenmayer – Editor-In-Chief

Communication between the campus community and Student Senate is incredibly important. However, the bylaw requiring biweekly attendance at Senate meetings was understandably overwhelming and undoable. This does not mean that there are not valuable ways to keep clubs involved in senate decisions.

Better alternatives can be achieved. If Student Senate had a club forum, or otherwise requested club input only once or twice per term, the pressure on clubs would lessen. Additionally, they could form an executive committee or position whose sole responsibility is club/organization outreach and communication. Clear communication is possible, perhaps in the form of emailed updates of any senate resolutions involving student clubs and organizations sent to executive boards of organizations.

Student Senate members or new club outreach positions could be encouraged or required to attend different club meetings throughout the term to better understand the clubs they work with. Ultimately, student club involvement in Senate is very possible, but there needs to be a better policy and implementation that considers other students more.

Ellen Miller Garrett – Managing Editor

This proposed bylaw already causes tension. People who want to just have fun in a club or organization are now expected to fulfill an ever increasing list of requirements in order to do so. The amount of work that is required by campus in order to host clubs is already so high.

For example, look at a club like Dungeons and Dragons, a group whose primary function is to book the Trustees Room on Saturdays and link people who are interested in D&D together. They not only have to fill the necessary exec positions, meet the minimum number of members, attend the Senate budgeting meeting and the DEI training every year; but also would have to go to Senate meetings, five times a term for two hours, so that Senate can know that their club does things.

With the over 108 organizations on campus, and the statistics of students overburdening themselves with organizations along with the amount of crossover between clubs of said students — where do they expect people to find the time and effort to attend these meetings? There is already such a great struggle to even get people to show up to anything at all for an organization – which in part, is not helped by the fact that there are all these insane amounts of requirements in order to be a club.

Red Engel – Graphics Editor

There is potential in this bylaw. With participation severely down on campus, there is a need for the general student body to come together, and to understand what is happening in Senate. However, with the understanding that participation is down, the bylaw in its current form is unmanageable.

Many clubs are barely keeping their heads above the water right now, functioning with extremely limited executive teams, and fluctuating attendance. The students that are on exec for clubs tend to have multiple clubs they are responsible for, not to mention the class loads and other responsibilities all students attend to. Finding a student on exec with the free time to attend the Senate meetings at that specific time every two weeks is difficult.

The way the bylaw is now, the few students available at that time would attend, representing several clubs, possibly clubs that they are not involved in. Actual active members from every club will not all have the opportunity to spend several hours watching a Senate meeting.

Selah Dow – Copy Editor

Leave a Comment
More to Discover
About the Contributors
Eleanor Lindenmayer
Eleanor Lindenmayer, Editor-In-Chief
Eleanor Lindenmayer '25 (she/her) is a journalism major. She started working for TKS as a staff writer when she was in her first year. She has also worked as the discourse editor and is now the Editor-in-Chief. Eleanor has also been published at Tri States Public Radio, where she was an intern and a freelancer. Eleanor was born and raised in the pacific northwest and will argue that there is no better place on this earth. Awards Illinois College Press Association 2024
  • 1st Place In Depth Reporting
  • 1st Place News
  • 1st Place Feature
Illinois College Press Association 2023
  • 2nd Place Columns
  • Honorable Mention Columns
Knox College 2023 Ida M. Tarbell Memorial Prize For Investigative Reporting    
Red Engel
Red Engel, Graphics Editor
Sasse/Red Engel '25, (he/they) is an Art History major with a Chemistry minor. They joined TKS in 2021 as the graphics editor and have continued in that position since. He is in charge of social media and the creation of the magazines. He is from Chicago, Illinois, and their current goal in life is to work one day at DC Comics, as a comic book artist.
Ellen/Kilroy Miller Garrett
Ellen/Kilroy Miller Garrett, Managing Editor
Ellen/Kilroy Miller Garrett '24 (they/them) is a Gender & Womens Studies major. They are the managing editor for The Knox Student. In their free time, they also work on WVKC, Knox's radio station. They have a tiny little dog (Frankie) who loves to join in on staff meetings. Awards Theodore Hazen Kimbale Memorial Award in Journalism - Feature article, 2023
Selah Dow
Selah Dow, Copy Editor
Selah Dow '25 (any pronouns) is a history major and a double minor in education and spanish. is the copy editor for TKS. They are from Boulder Colorado, and have had 5 cats throughout their life, all of which are orange tabbies.
Julia Maron
Julia Maron, Staff Writer
Julia Maron '26 (she/her) is a staff writer in TKS since her freshman year. She is a psychology and creative writing double major. Julia spends her free time writing, drawing, profoundly reflecting upon the deepest secrets of the human physical existence, and reading.

Comments (0)

All The Knox Student Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *